The series, The Met Live in HD, this year includes not only live operatic performances, but a documentary film. The Audition, a feature-length film directed by Susan Froemke, follows the finalists through their last week in the preparations for the 2007 Metropolitan Opera National Council Auditions, the most prestigious American singing competition, one that has launched the careers of many singers who have gone on to international stardom, including Renée Fleming, Thomas Hampson, Susan Graham, Ben Heppner, Deborah Voight, Nathan Gunn, Stephanie Blythe, and Samuel Ramey.
While The Audition bears some resemblance to the competition reality shows that have become a national obsession — behind-the-scenes interviews with the contestants that include surprising self revelations, the uneasy mix of camaraderie and competitiveness among the contestants, the anxiety of competing and the agonizing wait to hear the outcome, the judges’ frank deliberations about the performers — this is a far classier enterprise. The biggest difference is the attitude of the hosts, who on TV ramp up the anxiety and drama by relentlessly reminding the contestants that someone is going be eliminated, and that at the end, anyone could be publicly humiliated by the judges by having every flaw of their presentation exposed, often with barely contained contempt or malicious glee. Here, the staff of the Metropolitan Opera works tirelessly with the singers during the week between the semi-finals and finals with the sincere desire to help every competitor achieve his or her highest potential. The 11 finalists are treated with the utmost respect and are constantly reminded that regardless of the outcome, anyone who has made it this far has extraordinary talent and discipline. (Even Renée Fleming had to compete three times before she won.) The warmly personal nurturing that the singers receive from conductor Marco Armiliato, vocal coach Carrie-Anne Matheson, and other Met staffers is a testimony to their desire to help each of the singers succeed.
Froemke homes in especially on the stories of seven of the singers, and suspense is created by knowing that there can only be five or six winners, wondering how any of these incredible artists and individuals could possibly not win. She focuses on three of the tenors, each with a distinctive voice, story, and personality. Michael Fabiano is intensely driven and moody, characteristics that fit his Italianate performance of Lensky’s aria from Eugene Onegin perfectly. Alek Shrader’s easy-going confidence and charm give him the mischievous bravado ideally suited to “Ah, Mes Amis,” from La Fille du Régiment, an aria notorious for its nine high C’s, which he learned in less than a week and nailed with apparent effortlessness. The oldest contestant at 30, Ryan Smith, optimistic and engaging in the face of much adversity, was making a last attempt at an operatic career, and amazed himself with the passion and poise he brought to “E la solita storia del pastor,” from Cilea’s L’Arlesiana. (The tragic postscript to the film is that Smith, after making his professional debut at the Met, succumbed to cancer last fall.)
The Audition will be released on DVD this summer and ought to be of interest to any opera lover, not only for the beautiful singing, but for the vivid glimpse it gives of the world behind the curtain.
Watch the trailer for the film.