Matt Collar: OK, so either America is getting it wrong or the Vote for the Worst people are finally having an effect this year. How else do you explain Amanda Overmyer getting through? And she sounded even worse in the group performance. Nonetheless, last night was perhaps the most interesting results show since Daughtry got the early boot. You couldn’t have scripted a better exit for young Alaina Whittaker, who will probably get a call from Olivia Newton-John this week. Not much to say really about Jason Yeager as his leaving was inevitable. Robbie Carrico is perhaps a bit more of a surprise given his vocal ability, but he never really connected with the audience and did protest a little too much about not being a “rock” singer. It is also too bad for Alexandréa Lushington, who maybe had the most chance for improving during the competition, and her jazz fusion-inflected performances will be missed.
Andrew Leahey: I’m really going to miss saying the name “Lushington.” And while Alexandréa wasn’t my favorite vocalist by any means, I’d sell my upper limbs to get Amanda off this show and out of my life. She and Luke both deserved to go home this week, as did Kady Malloy (who, despite being quite pretty, has yet to bring that attractive quality to her performances). Alaina’s elimination was teary and heartfelt, providing one of the first genuinely moving moments of the season — or at least the first one that didn’t involve David Archuleta. Kudos to Ryan Seacrest for handling the situation well, and to the female contestants for lending their emotional and vocal support (although if I were Alaina, hearing Amanda’s nicotine-clogged voice in my right ear would’ve made me cry even harder).
The sacking of Robbie Carrico also caught me a bit off-guard, as did Simon’s scathing commentary. The dude had just been eliminated, Simon — there was no need to deliver one last “You’re not a rocker” potshot! But Robbie took the metaphorical kick-in-the-balls like a man, sang his final song with gusto, and presumably left the building with that supermodel (his girlfriend? his wife?) who was waiting for him on the Idol balcony. Hey, at least he went out like a rockstar.
Andy Kellman: It’s not quite as off as when Nikki stayed and Tamyra got the boot (during season one), or when Jennifer, Fantasia, and LaToya were in the bottom three (during season three), but Amanda lasting longer than Alexandréa is about as foul as it gets. Alexandréa stumbled a couple times, no doubt — it’s not like she even had a shot at making it to the very end — but watching her approach her potential for a few more weeks would’ve been far more engaging than whatever remaining amount of Amanda we are going to be dealt.
This also goes to show how young, aspiring singers have to be careful about when to audition for American Idol. If you’re good enough to make it to the top 24, and you get ejected early, you might impair or ruin your chances for success later on. If you wait it out a few years, until your early 20s, when you’ve become more seasoned, you might have a greater shot of making it further. Alexandréa’s 17 and has both obvious talent and a lot of room for development. Hopefully she’ll keep performing and improving and will not run into too many obstacles or be written off as a failed AI contestant.